which trip is better for a first timer w/ 9 days

For a first time visitor with 9 days (arriving in San Jose) which itinerary sounds better? San Jose airport –> Dominical –> Manual antonio –> monteverde –> arenal –> airport  …..OR…… San jose airport –> Limon/Puerto Viejo –> los quetzales national park –> dominical –> airport ( I am renting a 4×4 I love to hike, swim, surf, and eat)